Hold Up, Buttercup! Is the AI Party Already Over? (Economist Says 'Probably')

Michael Isih
7/22/2025
5 min read
Article
Thinking man with question mark

Alright, friend, let's have a little chat, shall we? Grab your favorite beverage (mine’s currently lukewarm coffee – glamourous, I know) and settle in. Today, we’re diving headfirst into a slightly controversial, definitely thought-provoking topic: the AI boom. Or, more accurately, whether it's all just a big, shiny, algorithmically-powered mirage.

Now, I know, I know. AI is everywhere. It's writing your marketing copy (badly, probably), 'improving' your customer service (by making it infinitely more frustrating), and generally promising to usher in a utopian (or dystopian, depending on which sci-fi novel you last read) future. We're all supposed to be breathless with excitement. I mean, who doesn't want to be replaced by a sentient toaster oven?

But hold your horses (or should I say, your self-driving Teslas?). A certain Very Important Economist (we'll call him Dr. Smarty Pants for anonymity, because apparently, voicing dissent against the AI overlords is now a politically risky move) has come out and said that this whole AI shebang is more overhyped than the dot-com bubble of the 90s.

Yes, that dot-com bubble. The one that gave us Pets.com (remember the sock puppet? shudders), Webvan (delivering groceries before it was cool, but also before it was economically viable), and enough Geocities websites to make your eyes bleed. The era where adding '.com' to the end of your company name instantly tripled your stock price. Good times. Or, you know, a massive, unsustainable bubble destined to pop.

So, Dr. Smarty Pants is saying this AI frenzy is even bigger? Let's unpack that, shall we?

Why He Might Be Right (or, Why My Bank Account is Trembling)

Okay, I'm not an economist. My financial expertise extends to strategically hiding chocolate from my children. But even I can see a few potential parallels between the late 90s and today:

  • Irrational Exuberance (aka, Everyone's Gone Bonkers): Remember the feeling that anything internet-related was guaranteed to make you rich? We're seeing a similar vibe with AI. Every company is slapping an AI label on something, even if it's just a slightly smarter chatbot. Suddenly, it's the emperor's new clothes for software. If you don't have an AI strategy, you're practically a Luddite living in a cave, according to some investors. And that, my friends, is a recipe for… well, irrational exuberance.

  • The 'Future is Now!' Fallacy: In the dot-com era, everyone assumed the internet would immediately revolutionize everything. No more brick-and-mortar stores! Paperless offices! Flying cars powered by dial-up modems! (Okay, maybe not the last one). The reality, of course, was a bit more…gradual. The technology was there, but the infrastructure, adoption, and actual usefulness lagged behind the hype. Is AI facing a similar problem? We have impressive models, but are we truly solving valuable problems, or just finding increasingly sophisticated ways to generate cat videos? I mean, I love cat videos, but they aren't exactly revolutionizing the global economy.

  • Money, Money, Money (Must Be Funny) in the Rich Man's World: Loads of money flowed into internet startups, regardless of whether they had a viable business model. The focus was on growth, user acquisition, and market share, with profitability as an afterthought. (Remember Amazon being notoriously unprofitable for years?). We're seeing massive investments in AI companies, many of which are burning through cash at an alarming rate. Can they actually generate sustainable profits, or are they just riding the wave of venture capital funding?

  • The Skillset Shortage: Just as there was a desperate need for programmers and web developers in the late 90s, we're facing a shortage of skilled AI engineers, researchers, and data scientists now. This drives up salaries, creates bottlenecks, and potentially leads to lower-quality AI solutions. Plus, a lot of people are 'AI experts' because they took a weekend course. That's like saying I'm a brain surgeon because I watched an episode of Grey's Anatomy.

But Wait! There's Hope (Maybe...) – Why AI Isn't Exactly Like the Dot-Com Bubble

Now, before you start selling all your tech stocks and investing in gold bullion (which, by the way, is probably also overhyped), let's consider why AI might be different:

  • The Underlying Technology is Fundamentally Transformative: The internet did revolutionize the world. It just took longer than everyone expected, and the winners weren't necessarily the companies that existed during the initial bubble. Similarly, AI has the potential to be truly transformative. It's not just a fad; it's a powerful technology that can automate tasks, analyze data, and create new possibilities. The key is finding real applications, not just shiny demos.

  • Data, Data Everywhere: Unlike the early internet, we now have access to vast amounts of data that can be used to train and improve AI models. Data is the fuel that powers AI, and we're drowning in it. (Whether we're using it responsibly is another question entirely… but let's not get too philosophical.)

  • Infrastructure is More Mature: The internet infrastructure in the late 90s was, to put it mildly, flaky. Dial-up modems, limited bandwidth, and websites that took five minutes to load were the norm. Today, we have high-speed internet, cloud computing, and powerful hardware that can support complex AI models. The plumbing is in place; it's just a matter of building the right house.

  • Lessons Learned (Hopefully): We (or at least, the venture capitalists) should have learned some lessons from the dot-com bubble. Hopefully, they're being more discerning about where they invest their money, and focusing on companies with sustainable business models, not just hype. Although, judging by the number of AI-powered toothbrushes I've seen advertised, I'm not entirely convinced.

So, What Should We Do? (Besides Panic-Buying Toilet Paper)

Okay, so we've established that the AI boom might be a bit… exuberant. But that doesn't mean AI is going away. It just means we need to be a little more skeptical, a little more realistic, and a little less prone to chasing shiny objects. Here are a few suggestions:

  • Do Your Research: Don't just believe the hype. Before investing in an AI company (or even adopting an AI-powered tool), understand the technology, the business model, and the potential risks. Ask tough questions. Demand evidence. And, for the love of all that is holy, read the fine print.

  • Focus on Real Value: Look for AI solutions that solve real problems and deliver tangible value. Don't get distracted by bells and whistles. A chatbot that can tell you the weather is nice, but a chatbot that can automate customer support inquiries and free up your employees to focus on more important tasks is valuable.

  • Be Patient: AI is still in its early stages. It's going to take time for the technology to mature, for standards to emerge, and for us to figure out how to use it effectively. Don't expect overnight miracles. Rome wasn't built in a day, and neither was a truly sentient AI (thank goodness!).

  • Embrace the Skepticism: Question everything. Don't blindly accept the narrative that AI is going to solve all our problems. Be critical, be curious, and be willing to challenge the status quo. After all, healthy skepticism is the best antidote to irrational exuberance.

The Takeaway (In Case You Skipped to the End)

Dr. Smarty Pants might be right. The AI boom could be overhyped. But even if it is, AI is here to stay. The key is to approach it with a healthy dose of skepticism, a focus on real value, and a willingness to learn and adapt. And maybe, just maybe, avoid investing in any AI-powered dog grooming apps. (Unless, of course, your dog really needs a digital makeover).

So, what do you think? Is the AI party winding down, or are we just getting started? Let me know in the comments! I'm genuinely curious to hear your thoughts (and maybe get some investing advice, because, as I mentioned, my chocolate-hiding strategy isn't exactly Goldman Sachs-level expertise).

Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go yell at my smart fridge for ordering too much kale. Apparently, it thinks it knows what's best for me. The nerve!

Enjoyed this article? Share it with others!